Colfax (P) manufacturer envelopes. It also prints them, and the seventeen employees who do the printing are represented by LOCAL NO. 458-3M (D). P does not bother to participate in the collective bargaining negotiations between D and the Chicago Lithographers Association. Whenever D and the CLA sign a new collective bargaining agreement, the union sends P a summary of the changes that the new agreement has made in the old one which P signs and returns. If P doesn't like the terms negotiated by the CLA, it is free to do its own bargaining with D. In 1991 D sent a summary of the changes to P. The changes indicated that all presses operated as four-color presses would now require only three men to man them. P accepted the terms in the summary. When the actual agreement arrived, it contained a crucial typo, which supported P's understanding of the summary. When a corrected copy of the agreement finally arrived, the manning requirements stated in it were different from what P had understood from the summary. Four-color presses between 45 and 60 inches required three men, but all four-color presses over 60 inches required four men. P refused to sign the agreement, but D took the position that P was bound to it by its acceptance of the summary. P sued for a declaration that it has no collective bargaining contract D because the parties never agreed on an essential term--the manning requirements for P's printing presses. D counterclaimed for an order to arbitrate. The district judge granted summary judgment for D, concluding that the reference to the new manning requirement for a four-color 60-inch press in the summary of changes that P had accepted referred unambiguously to 60-inch presses and had no application to any other presses, such as P's 78-inch presses. P appealed.

This section contains the nature of the case and procedural background.

The legal issues presented in this case will be displayed here.

The court's holding and decision will be displayed here.

Legal analysis from Dean's Law Dictionary will be displayed here.