Uptegrove and the Stratton Area Citizens Committee filed a petition with D, seeking reclassification of Kidder Brook, an upland stream located in the towns of Jamaica and Stratton. P owned property along Kidder Brook. P had long-term plans for development and to that end held six land use permits. D initiated rulemaking proceedings, and D published a proposed rule to reclassify the brook. D held a public hearing and set a deadline for public comment. P asserted that the Due Process Clause of the United States Constitution required D to conduct formal, trial-like proceedings rather than an informal rulemaking procedure. P based this assertion on property rights in the land adjoining the brook and its plans for future development of the area. D rejected P's due process argument and proceeded to hear testimony. D extended the public comment period to July 20th to allow P time to file additional written materials. P presented approximately 125 pages of written testimony and supporting materials. P owned property on both sides of Kidder Brook and held six Act 250 land use permits involving these properties. P claimed that if the reclassification were allowed its permits would be subject to revocation or modification. P was about to request an Act 250 permit to construct 498 homes and an 18-hole golf course in the area. These plans could be significantly affected or prevented by the reclassification. D voted unanimously to proceed with adoption of the proposed rule to reclassify. D addressed P's issues and found P's concerns as speculative. P appealed alleging that D's actions were arbitrary, unreasonable, and 'contrary to law.' P's only claim on appeal was that D should have conducted 'a trial-type hearing to adjudicate disputed facts' raised by the petition. The court dismissed P's appeal. P appealed.

This section contains the nature of the case and procedural background.

The legal issues presented in this case will be displayed here.

The court's holding and decision will be displayed here.

Legal analysis from Dean's Law Dictionary will be displayed here.