Johnson v. Penny
779 N.W. 2d 412 (2010)
Holding & Decision
The court's holding and decision will be displayed here.
Nature Of The Case
This section contains the nature of the case and procedural background.
Facts
P and Larson entered into an oral contract whereby P agreed to remove rock from Larson's farmland in exchange for P receiving the value of the rock removed. Shortly after P began removing rock from Larson's land, the two entered into a second oral agreement. In exchange for P's right to keep the excavated rock extracted from Larson's land, P agreed to install drain tile in a low-lying area of Larson's farmland. P removed rock from Larson's land. He also installed drain tile. P claimed that he extracted approximately 1,100 tons of rock. P removed between three to five semi-truck loads from Larson's land. The rest was stored for removal at a later date. D learned that Larson had rock on his land that he wanted removed. D contacted Larson. Larson told D of the deal with P. Larson also told Penny that he would contact P to ask whether P intended on removing the stockpiled rock. P did not contact Larson, and eventually, Larson gave D permission to remove the rock. D paid nothing for the rock. P learned that his rock piles were no longer on Larson's land. P invoiced Larson on October 24, 2006, for his services in excavating and removing the rock. P also included an invoice for the installation of the drain tile. Larson neither responded to the letter nor paid the invoice. P sued Larson for breach of contract, conversion, restitution, constructive trust, and unjust enrichment. He amended his complaint to include D. The jury returned a verdict in favor of Larson and D. A hearing was held to consider P's equitable claims. The court concluded that Larson and D were unjustly enriched by the labor, equipment, and materials provided by P for the removal of the rock. Ds appealed. Ds claim that because the jury rendered a verdict against P on his breach of contract and conversion claims, the court erred in allowing unjust enrichment damages on the same facts.
Issues
The legal issues presented in this case will be displayed here.
Legal Analysis
Legal analysis from Dean's Law Dictionary will be displayed here.
© 2007-2025 ABN Study Partner