In 1974, a thief stole twelve lots of valuable antique silver from Mrs.Welch’s (P) home. A month later Kosasky (D) purchased 11 of the lots from a dealer in Brookline for $2,750. The price P had paid 12 years before was in excess of $40,000. In 1981, D approached a Boston dealer to sell the silver. Nine of the eleven lots were purchased for $40,000. One of the two lots not purchased was a set of three James II castors that P had purchased for $7,500 in 1971. The dealer recommended that they be restored to their original form and D sent them off to London. In 1981, P saw two of the stolen items in the dealer’s store window. Over the next year, P succeeded in recovering all the stolen items that had been purchased by D. P then sued in conversion and for damages to the James II castors. P got the judgment and the judge gave her damages of $10,000 for the loss of the silver for the 8 years, and $22,000 in diminution of value for the castors and $5,000 in consequential damages representing in part a fee of $994.78 paid to an attorney in connection with the recovery of the castors in London and in part of a $10,000 fee paid to another attorney who performed services to locate and recover all the items stolen including other works of art not mentioned in this suit. D appealed the diminution in value judgment.

This section contains the nature of the case and procedural background.

The legal issues presented in this case will be displayed here.

The court's holding and decision will be displayed here.

Legal analysis from Dean's Law Dictionary will be displayed here.