Foremost-Mckesson, Inc. v. Provident Securities Company

423 U.S. 232 (1976)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Provident (P) was a personal holding company. In 1968, it decided to liquidate its dissolve. Foremost (D) emerged as a potential purchaser, and then negotiations began with P wanting cash and D wanting to exchange stock. Eventually, a deal was reached for $4.25 million in cash and $49.75 million in convertible subordinated debentures. The agreement also allowed D to register the securities in the amount of $25 million to sell the debentures to the public. At the closing on October 15, 1992, D delivered to P the cash and a $40 million debenture. That was exchanged for two debentures of $25 million and $15 million. Another $2.5-million-dollar debenture was delivered to an escrow agent, and the balance of $7.25 million was delivered on October 20. These debentures were immediately converted into more than 10% of D's outstanding stock. The underwriting agreements were executed on October 21 for the $25 million, and P distributed the $15 and 7.25 million dollar debentures to its stockholders reducing the amount of common stock to less than 10%. P's holdings on October 20 were large enough to make it a beneficial owner of D under section 16(b). P was faced with a suit from D under 16(b) and thus filed for a declaration that it was not liable under 16(b). The district court granted summary judgment for P, and the Court of Appeals affirmed.