Manning v. Grimsley

643 F.2d 20 (1st Cir. 1981)

Facts

The Orioles and Red Sox were playing at Fenway. Grimsley (D) was warming up as a pitcher for Baltimore. While D was warming up, the spectators were constantly heckling him. At the end of the third inning, after his catcher left his position, D was walking over to the bench. D faced the bleachers and wound up as though to pitch in the direction of the plate and the ball left his hand at a 90-degree angle from the pitcher’s mound directly toward the hecklers. The ball passed through the wire mesh and hit a heckler. The judge entered a verdict for Ds on the count of battery, and the jury returned a verdict for D on the negligence count. This appeal resulted on the battery count.