International Minerals And Chemical Corp. v. Llano, Inc.

770 F.2d 879 (10th 1985), cert. denied, 475 U.S. 1015 (1986)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

International (P) sought a declaratory judgment to excuse itself from performance under a natural gas contract with Llano (D). P was required to take 4.8m BTU's of gas from Ilano per day or to pay for that amount anyway. P was engaged in the business of operating a potash mine and processing facility and operated nine submerged combustion evaporators. These evaporators emitted large amounts of pollution. In December 1978 New Mexico decided to regulate those emissions. P was forced to look for alternative methods of production and notified D that its gas consumption would be 50-60% of normal and that in response to environmental problems, the reduced gas consumption might be permanent and thereby invoking the force majure clause in the contract between them. This resulted in P not taking is required take or pay amounts from D during the last 18 months of the contract. The trial court found for D even though D could sell the gas at a higher price than it would have received from P. D appealed.