Mayhew v. Sullivan Mining Co.

76 Me. 100 (1884)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Mayhew (P) was working as a contractor for the Sullivan Mining Co. (D). During the course of P's work, one of D's workers cut a hole in the platform near where P was working. This workman did not mark or identify the hole and did not tell P of its existence. P fell through the hole, causing serious injury. P sued, claiming D had 'carelessly and negligently cut the hole without placing a barrier or warning by it.' At trial, the court refused D's question of whether or not it was a custom to mark holes that were dug in the platform. The jury found negligence and returned a verdict for P for $2500. D appealed, claiming that since they were conforming to custom, they were using average ordinary care.